Impostor Feelings and Vulnerable Narcissism Overlap But Remain Distinct, Study Finds
Distinguishing Psychological Constructs
The research shows complex nuances. Impostor feelings and vulnerable narcissism overlap. However, they are separate psychological constructs. This work was published in Personality and Social Psychology Bulletin .
Wellness insights:
The Impostor Phenomenon
Impostor syndrome involves persistent feelings of inadequacy. This occurs despite objective proof of competence. Individuals often attribute success to luck or external factors. They fear others will discover their supposed incompetence. These feelings often accompany anxiety, low self-esteem, and perfectionism.
Vulnerable Narcissism Versus Grandiose Narcissism
Impostor syndrome and narcissism both involve self-worth struggles. Grandiose narcissism shows exaggerated self-importance and dominance. Vulnerable narcissism manifests as insecurity and emotional sensitivity. Vulnerable narcissism shares traits with impostor syndrome. These include fragile self-esteem and reliance on external validation. Narcissism also includes superior entitlement, which impostor syndrome lacks.
Childhood Experiences and Attachment
Parental experiences matter significantly. Overly controlling or critical parenting links to vulnerable narcissism and impostor feelings. Supportive parenting correlates with lower incidence of these traits. Both impostor syndrome and vulnerable narcissism link to insecure adult attachment. Specifically, attachment anxiety is a common factor.
Study Methodology and Findings
Kristina Klug from Goethe University, Frankfurt, led the investigation. The hypothesis was that impostor syndrome and vulnerable narcissism link to childhood experiences and adult attachment. The sample included 339 participants aged 16 to 80. Data was collected via an online survey from February to April 2023. Participants completed several scales. These included the Impostor-Selbstkonzept-Fragebogen and the Revised Adult Attachment Scale.
Key Results
A strong link existed between impostor syndrome and vulnerable narcissism. The link to grandiose narcissism was much weaker. Strong impostor feelings correlated with lower trust and higher attachment anxiety. Participants often recalled parents as more controlling and dismissive. Only parental control and overprotection uniquely linked to both impostor syndrome and vulnerable narcissism when all three parenting dimensions were combined. Emotional warmth showed no link to either narcissism type.
More stories: